Category: -Rules of Evidence

Rules of Evidence – Effective February 29, 2024

HJR013 (the joint resolution amending Rule 7B of the Utah Rules of Criminal Procedure and Rule 1102 of the Utah Rules of Evidence regarding admissibility of reliable hearsay in criminal preliminary examinations) became effective immediately yesterday after having passed both the House and the Senate by the required 2/3 majority vote (per Art. VIII, Sec. 4 of the Constitution).

As amended, Rule 7B(b) permits findings of probable cause to be based “in whole or in part, on reliable hearsay.” However, as amended, Rule 1102(d)(2)(e) conditions the admissibility of reliable hearsay on the presentation of testimony under Rule 7B(d)(2). In turn, Rule 7B(d)(2) permits a prosecutor to “present the testimony of any relevant witness,” including “of an investigating peace officer,” and permits either side to “introduce, through direct or cross examination, the testimony of an investigating peace officer,” including as to “the totality or details of an investigation of the crime for which the defendant is charged.” Additionally, Rule 1102(e) specifies that the prosecutor “is not required to introduce evidence” corroborating a declarant’s statement submitted under Rule 1102(b)(8), and “may, but is not required to, call the declarant” of such a statement at the preliminary examination. Further, Rule 1102(e) states that paragraph (e) “does not otherwise limit a defendant’s right to call witnesses under Rule 7B . . . .”

URE1102. Reliable Hearsay in Criminal Preliminary Examinations. Amend.

Continue Reading
Continue Reading

Rules of Evidence – Effective November 1, 2023

URE0101. Scope; Definitions. Amend. The amendments add certain definitions in subparagraph (b) to clarify the applicability of the Utah Rules of Evidence to juvenile court proceedings, and add subparagraph (c) to specify that in the event of conflict between these definitions and the Utah Rules of Juvenile Procedure, the latter rules govern.

URE0412. Admissibility of Victim’s Sexual Behavior of Predisposition. Amend. Subparagraph (a) is amended to omit the specific reference to “juvenile delinquency” proceedings. In view of the proposed amendments to URE 101 and 1101, the reference is unnecessary. The reference could also be confusing since other rules that likewise apply to juvenile delinquency proceedings do not include such specific references.

URE0615. Excluding Witnesses. Amend. Subparagraphs (d) and (e) are amended to omit the specific references to “juvenile delinquency” proceedings. In view of the proposed amendments to URE 101 and 1101, the references are unnecessary. The references could also be confusing since other rules that likewise apply to juvenile delinquency proceedings do not include such specific references.

URE1101. Applicability of Rules. Amend. Subparagraph (a) is amended to add a provision clarifying that the Utah Rules of Evidence apply to “all juvenile court proceedings unless stated otherwise in the Utah Rules of Juvenile Procedure.”

Supreme Court Order

Continue Reading

Rules of Evidence – Effective May 3, 2023

URE1102. Reliable Hearsay in Criminal Preliminary Examinations.  In its 2023 legislative session, the Utah Legislature approved SJR006, modifying Rule 1102 of the Utah Rules of Evidence. The amendment permits a prosecutor, or staff for a prosecutor, to transcribe a declarant’s statement or assist a declarant in drafting a statement, so long as the prosecutor, or staff for the prosecutor, does not draft the statement or tamper with the witness.

Continue Reading

Rules of Evidence – Effective November 1, 2022

URE0412. Admissibility of Victim’s Sexual Behavior or Predisposition. AMEND. Rule 412 is amended to clarify that the Rule is applicable to juvenile delinquency proceedings as well as criminal proceedings.

URE0504. Legal Professional – Client. AMEND. Rule 504 is amended to expand the lawyer-client privilege to cover not only confidential client communications with lawyers, but also other legal professionals including licensed paralegal practitioners.

Supreme Court Order

 

Continue Reading

Rules of Evidence – Effective May 1, 2022

URE0512. Victim Communications (AMEND). Clarifies that URE 510 applies to this rule. Disclosures of the following confidential communications will now waive the privilege: 1) disclosures required under Title 62A, Chapter 4a, Child and Family Services or UCA § 62A-3-305, 2) evidence of a victim being in clear and immediate danger to the victim’s self or others, and 3) evidence that the victim has committed a crime, plans to commit a crime, or intends to conceal a crime.

URE1101. Applicability of Rules (AMEND). Clarifies that the Utah Rules of Evidence are inapplicable to proceedings for revoking probation, unless the court for good cause otherwise orders. Amends the committee note following State v. Weeks, 61 P.3d 1000.

 

Supreme Court Order

Continue Reading
Continue Reading
Continue Reading
Continue Reading
Continue Reading