Rule 29A.
Visual recording of statement or testimony of child victim or witness of sexual
or physical abuse - Conditions of admissibility.
(a) In any delinquency proceeding or
proceeding under Section 78A-6-702 or Section 78A-6-703 concerning a charge of
child abuse or of a sexual offense against a child, the oral statement of a
victim or witness younger than 14 years of age may be recorded prior to the
filing of a petition, and upon motion and for good cause shown is admissible as
evidence in any court proceeding regarding the offense if all of the following
conditions are met:
(a)(1) no attorney
for either party is in the child's presence when the statement is recorded;
(a)(2) the
recording is visual and aural and is recorded on film or videotape or by other
electronic means;
(a)(3) the
recording equipment is capable of making an accurate recording, the operator of
the equipment is competent, and the recording is accurate and has not been
altered;
(a)(4) each voice
in the recording is identified;
(a)(5) the person
conducting the interview of the child in the recording is present at the
proceeding and is available to testify and be cross-examined by either party;
(a)(6) the minor
and the minor’s attorney are provided an opportunity to view the recording
before it is shown to the court;
(a)(7) the court
views the recording and determines that it is sufficiently reliable and
trustworthy and that the interest of justice will best be served by admission
of the statement into evidence; and
(a)(8) the child is
available to testify and to be cross-examined at trial, either in person or as
provided by Subsection (b) or (c), or the court determines that the child is
unavailable as a witness to testify at trial under the Utah Rules of Evidence.
For purposes of this subsection "unavailable" includes a
determination, based on medical or psychological evidence or expert testimony,
that the child would suffer serious emotional or mental strain if required to
testify at trial.
(b) In any proceeding concerning a charge of
child abuse or of a sexual offense against a child, the court may order, upon
motion of the prosecution and for good cause shown, that the testimony of any
witness or victim younger than 14 years of age be taken in a room other than
the courtroom. All of the following conditions shall be observed:
(b)(1) Only the judge, attorneys for each
party, persons necessary to operate equipment, and a counselor or therapist
whose presence contributes to the welfare and emotional well-being of the child
may be with the child during the testimony. The minor may also be present
during the child's testimony unless the minor consents to be hidden from the
child's view, or the court determines that the child will suffer serious
emotional or mental strain if required to testify in the minor’s presence, or
that the child's testimony will be inherently unreliable if required to testify
in the minor’s presence. If the court makes that determination, or if the minor
consents:
(b)(1)(A) the minor
may not be present during the child's testimony;
(b)(1)(B) the court
shall ensure that the child cannot hear or see the minor ;
(b)(1)(C) the court
shall advise the child prior to testifying that the minor is present at the
trial and may listen to the child's testimony;
(b)(1)(D) the minor
shall be permitted to observe and hear the child's testimony, and the court
shall ensure that the minor has a means of two-way telephonic communication
with defense counsel during the child's testimony; and
(b)(1)(E) the
conditions of a normal court proceeding shall be approximated as nearly as
possible.
(b)(2) Only the judge and attorneys may
question the child.
(b)(3) As much as possible, persons
operating equipment shall be confined to an adjacent room or behind a screen or
mirror so the child cannot see or hear them.
(c) In any case concerning a charge of child
abuse or of a sexual offense against a child, the court may order, upon motion
of the prosecution and for good cause shown, that the testimony of any witness
or victim younger than 14 years of age be taken outside the courtroom and be
recorded. That testimony is admissible as evidence, for viewing in any court
proceeding regarding the charges if the provisions of Subsection (b) are
observed, in addition to the following provisions:
(c)(1) the
recording is both visual and aural and recorded on film or videotape or by
other electronic means;
(c)(2) the
recording equipment is capable of making an accurate recording, the operator is
competent, and the recording is accurate and is not altered;
(c)(3) each voice
on the recording is identified; and
(c)(4) each party
is given an opportunity to view the recording before it is shown in the
courtroom.
(d) If the court orders that the testimony
of a child be taken under Subsection (b) or (c), the child may not be required
to testify in court at any proceeding where the recorded testimony is used.